Steamfitter - Pipefitter (SFP)

2022 Guide - Fourth Period Package (1 Module) Comments

Date: 1/10/2024 1:38:59 PM
Module: 070403d
Version: 24
Page: 18 - 19
Comment: For the heading 6.4.9.5 on page 18, multiple sub-parts are shown (a, b, c, d). It looks like part (c) and (d) are incorrectly formatted, in that they don't each start on a new line. Then on the top of page 19, there is another instance of 6.4.9.5 (c). Perhaps double-check all the formatting for 6.4.9.5 and its corresponding sub-parts.
Status: Approved for Review

Date: 1/10/2024 1:20:17 PM
Module: 070403d
Version: 24
Page: 17 & 19
Comment: ILM 070403d - Critical Lifts v.24: On pages 16 through 19, regarding the safe limit of approach to electrical lines, the text refers to tables, figures, and schedules from OHS and CSA codes. I find some of these references confusing because it's not always clear if the text refers to the ILM Table 3, the OHS Table 3, or the CSA Table 3. For example, page 17, ILM Table 2 - Safe Distances of Approach Distances, appears to be a copy of OHS Schedule 4 & OHS Table 1. I suggest ILM Table 3 be renamed to Figure 7. On ILM page 19, ILM Table 3 appears to be a reproduction of CSA Table 4. I suggest it be renamed to Figure 8. Of course, if my suggestion is implemented, any references in the text to ILM Tables 2 & 3 would have to be repaired. Also, on page 17, under the heading of CSA Z150 6.4.9.1, it states "... energized conductors as shown in Table 4 [reproduced on p. 24]" I believe that should say "reproduced on page 19".
Status: Approved for Review


Archived Comments

Year: 2021

10/13/2021 11:50:51 AM
Module: 070403d
Version: 22
Page: 10
Comment: The last paragraph on page 10 references code CSA-Z150 section 4.1.1.2, and states that Table 1 is "Included below for Reference). However, the included Table is the wrong table. The correct "Table 1" from CSA-Z150 (version 2020) is on page 12 of the ILM but is mislabeled as Table 2. And page 11 is a nearly complete text duplicate of page 10, aside from the heading "Load Weight and Crane Capacity". My suggestions are: replace Table 1 on page 10 with Table 2 from page 12; delete page 11. Edit the paragraph at the top of the old page 12 to correct for the changes to Tables 1 and 2.
Status: Implemented

Return to Comments   Order Modules